So a Couple Years Ago I Pay a Guy $250 To Fix a Roof Leak...

And he claims it’s a cedar trim piece under a window causing the problems and replaces it. Then never comes back to fix the cosmetic damage and collect another $250. The cosmetic damage was the garage ceiling and the laundry room ceiling right next to the garage.

It seemed to work until the recent rains, which caused me to investigate myself. Any ideas on how to best approach the fix? I’m thinking if I just rubberize the attic area, it will just make the water go somewhere else.

Garage Ceiling After The Rain (laundry room unaffected)

Garage Attic With Obvious Problem

Roof Where Attic Leak Is Occurring

The Roof Water Gravity Origins

Overall Roof View